(925) 232-1719 Submit a work order
Facility Solutions

Before Blaming the Contractor, Ask These 5 Questions

Five questions help commercial property teams separate repair scope, equipment history and deferred maintenance before deciding the next action.

M5 Services2 min read

A repair visit ends. A building problem returns. The natural question is: “Did the contractor fix anything?”

It is a fair question. But it is not the only one.

A failed repair and a long-standing maintenance backlog are different problems. Sometimes both exist. Before deciding who is responsible, separate the condition of the equipment, the work that was authorized, and what happened afterward.

Here are five questions worth asking.

1 What problem was the contractor hired to solve?

Start with the approved scope, not everyone’s memory of the conversation.

Was the assignment to diagnose a failure, replace a component, restore temporary operation, or address the entire system? A limited repair should not be presented as a complete solution. Equally, a full-system outcome should not be assumed when only a specific component repair was authorized.

Ask for the original finding, recommended work, approved work and any exclusions in one place.

2 What condition was the equipment in before the visit?

Look for service history, documented findings, photographs and previous recommendations.

An equipment failure after a service visit does not, by itself, establish what caused it. The history helps distinguish a new problem from an existing issue that remained unresolved.

This is not about giving anyone a free pass. Contractors should explain their findings clearly, and property teams should be able to see what was known before approving the next step.

3 Which recommendations were completed, deferred or declined?

A proposal is not a repair. A budget line is not completed maintenance.

For each recommendation, record whether it was approved, performed, postponed or rejected, and why. Include who owns the next decision and when it will be revisited.

Deferral may be a practical budget decision, but it should be a visible decision. It should not quietly disappear from the record when the next service provider arrives.

4 Are we maintaining the equipment and operating it correctly?

Maintenance and operation are connected, but they are not interchangeable.

ENERGY STAR notes that poorly operated equipment can waste energy even when it is maintained, and recommends documenting changes to schedules, set points and control strategies. Ask the qualified service team whether the equipment’s operation still fits the building’s current use.

This is a review question, not an invitation for unqualified staff to adjust equipment.

5 What evidence will show that the next action worked?

Agree on the result before approving another visit: what will be checked, who will verify it, and what remaining limitations will be documented.

The goal is not to protect a contractor from accountability or blame an owner for every failure. It is to identify the actual problem and make the next decision with better information.

Good maintenance conversations move beyond “Who caused this?” to “What do we know, what remains unresolved, and who is responsible for the next step?”

Ready when you are

Have a repair on the list?

Send us the work order. We handle day-to-day repairs and on-call dispatch, and we work in ServiceChannel and CorrigoPro.